Baskets
Served with French fries, slaw and choice of tartar or cocktail sauce
Fried Shrimp Basket
Plump shrimp fried to perfection!
$14.99
Chix-N-Chips
Crunchy fried chicken tenders
$12.99
Fish-N-Chips
Fresh fish nuggets dusted in seasoned flour. Then deep fried a golden brown
$13.99
Fried Clam Basket
Our lightly seasoned, single breaded, deep-fried clam strips
$14.99
Appetizers
Garlic Parmesan Oysters
Baked with parmesan cheese and garlic butter.
Half dozen $13.99
Full dozen $23.99
Cajun style add + $0.75
Stuffed Clams
Lobster and crabmeat stuffed baked clams
$12.99
Steamed Mussels
One pound of fresh farm raised mussels sautéed in wine sauce, onions, garlic, and tomatoes, sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Served with garlic toast
$13.99
Baja Fish Tacos
Two crunchy corn taco shells loaded with our crunchy fried fish, shredded cabbage, chili tequila lime sauce, and pico de gallo served with our chipotle crème sauce
$9.99
Fried Chicken Livers
Lightly breaded and deep fried and served with our spicy honey mustard sauce
$9.99
Cajun Bacon Wrapped Scallops
A house favorite! Three large sea scallops wrapped with bacon and grilled to perfection with our honey lime sauce
$18.99
Coconut Shrimp
Premium shrimp dipped in coconut batter, rolled in shredded coconut, then deep fried. Served with island dipping sauce
$12.99
Crunchy Chicken Tenders
Fresh chicken tenders, corn flake breaded, then golden fried
$8.99
Conch Fritters
Loaded with conch (konk), served with Bahamian fritter sauce
$10.99
Seared Yellow Fin Tuna*
Sushi grade tuna served with wasabi, soy, and ginger
$14.99
Blue Cheese & Balsamic Tater Chips
House-made potato chips covered with melted bleu cheese fondue and finished with balsamic glaze, tomatoes, and green onions, perfect for sharing!
$16.99
Bacon Wrapped Plantains
With orange chipotle glaze
$8.99
Jumbo Chicken Wings, Mon!
Lightly breaded, deep fried, and tossed in your choice of sauce; key lime habanero, teriyaki garlic, bourbon BBQ, Sriracha honey, or Jamaican jerk BBQ sauce
$13.99
Bleu cheese & celery + $0.99
Extra sauce + $0.50
Fried Calamari
Fresh calamari coated in a seasoned flour, then deep fried
$15.99
Queso Cheese Dip
Served with tri-color corn chips
Queso cheese $9.99
Crunchy Fish Fingers
Fresh fish strips rolled in corn flakes, then deep fried golden brown
$8.99
Smoked Fish Dip
Mild fish blend smoked then blended to create a taste sensation. Includes diced tomato, onion, and jalapeño on request
$12.99
Oak Grilled Teriyaki Chicken & Pineapple Kabobs
$8.99
Ahi Tuna Tartar*
Sashimi grade yellowfin tuna diced and mixed with sweet Thai chili and sriracha. Garnished with green onions and wasabi cream sauce. Served over chips
$16.99
Sides
French Fries
$3.99
Cole Slaw
$2.99
Bimini Bread
$2.99
Veggie, Potato or Rice
$2.99
Pasta & Other Stuff
Seafood Lasagna
Layers of lasagna noodles filled with blue crab claw meat, shrimp and sea scallops, ricotta, mozzarella, and provolone cheeses, then topped with a creamy tomato-alfredo sauce
Lighter appetite $18.99
Full portion $21.99
Lobster & Shrimp Mac & Cheese
Spicy cheese, lobster and shrimp – yum!
$19.99
Seafood Scampi
Scallops and shrimp in garlic butter over fettuccine
$22.99
Stuffed Sweet Potato
Jumbo sweet potato stuffed with pulled pork, green onions and topped with bourbon BBQ sauce
$12.99
Drunken Sweet Potato
A house favorite! This ain’t your ordinary, small sweet potato! Brown sugar, Myers’s dark Jamaican rum and special tropical spices
$6.99
Poke Bowls
All come with cucumber, carrots, sesame seed and green onions. Served over coconut rice
$13.99
Shrimp: chilled shrimp with sweet Thai chili and wasabi cream sauce
Tuna: chilled sushi grade tuna with special sauce
Thai chicken: grilled chicken breast, pineapple, crunchy fried onions and peanut sauce
Teriyaki chicken: grilled chicken, pineapple and teriyaki sauce
Burgers
Choice, half pound oak-grilled Angus beef. Served with chips $13.99. Add fries for $1.99. Add cheese for $1.75. Gluten free bun add $1.49
Overwater Grill Burger
Cajun bacon and melted bleu cheese
$16.99
Bourbon Burger
Grilled onions, pepper jack cheese, pickled jalapeños, crunchy fried onions and bourbon BBQ
$15.99
Hawaiian Burger
Grilled pineapple slice, fried onions and our teriyaki glaze
$15.99
Veggie Burger
$12.99
Lobster & Crab Burger
Our burger topped with a lobster crab cake. Bring your banker!
$19.99
For Others” Burger
$75
Sandwiches & Wraps
Most items are served with lettuce, tomato, onion, and chips | Add fries $1.99 | Choice of honey lime, Jamaican jerk, garlic teriyaki, apricot ginger lime, Thai peanut sauce on grilled items. American, Swiss, cheddar, provolone, pepper jack, bacon, sautéed onion or bleu cheese add $1.75 | Gluten-free bun add $1.49
Oak Grilled Fish Sandwiches
With your choice of baste or sauce
Mahi, tuna or salmon $16.99
Grouper $19.99
Lobster-N-Crab Cake
Our special blend of lobster and crab meat fried or sautéed
$18.99
Pineapple & Teriyaki Mahi Sandwich
Oak-grilled mahi and pineapple with teriyaki glaze and citrus mayo
Mahi Sandwich $17.99
Substitute chicken $14.99
Crunchy Fish or Chicken BLT Wrap
Your choice of crunchy fish or chicken, smoked bacon, fresh ripe tomatoes, and iceberg lettuce tossed with our cajun mayo and wrapped in a seasoned herb wrap
$13.99
Crunchy Fish Sandwich
Mild fish fillet dusted in seasoned flour, rolled in corn flakes, deep fried
$12.99
Abaco Fish Sandwich
Coconut fried fish fillet topped with mango chutney and smothered with melted Swiss cheese
$13.99
Cuban Sandwich
Mojo-marinated fresh pork, baked ham, genoa salami, imported Swiss, dill pickle, and yellow mustard on fresh pressed Cuban bread
$13.99
Pulled Pork Sandwich with Cole Slaw
Our pork is slow-cooked with your choice of our Jamaican jerk, Carolina gold, North Carolina vinegar, bourbon or hickory smoked BBQ sauces
$12.99
Buffalo Wrap
Your choice of shrimp or chicken coated with our key lime habanero sauce and wrapped together with our bleu cheese slaw
$12.99
Oak Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Your choice of style
Oak Grilled Chicken with your choice of baste $13.99
Thai: Thai peanut sauce and crunchy fried onions $13.99
Mahi Reuben
Our grilled mahi with sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island dressing on toasted rye bread
$16.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken breast fried and coated with Key lime habareno sauce.
$13.99
Something sweet
Mike’s Key Lime Pie
Slice $7.99
Chocolate Seduction Cake
$7.99
House Made Banana Pudding
$5.99
Entrees
Entrees are served with your choice of potato of the day, rice or French Fries, and vegetable du jour
Oak-Grilled Fish Entrees
Grouper, mahi or tuna a generous portion of the freshest fish we can buy. Oak grilled to perfection and finished with any of our sauces (honey lime sauce, apricot ginger lime, citrus butter, garlic teriyaki, black cherry pepper, or cajun seasoning)
MP
Cajun Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops
A house favorite! Large bacon wrapped sea scallops oak-grilled with our honey lime sauce
Single skewer (4) $28.99
Double skewer (8) $36.99
Grilled Shrimp
Skewered, oak-grilled shrimp seasoned with your choice of honey lime sauce, citrus butter, cajun seasoning, or Jamaican jerk
Lighter appetite $15.99
Full portion $17.99
Fried Shrimp
Lighter appetite $15.99
Full portion $17.99
Coconut Shrimp
Butterflied shrimp dipped in coconut rum batter, rolled in shredded coconut then deep fried, served with our island dipping sauce
Lighter appetite $18.99
Full portion $21.99
Thai Mahi
Oak-grilled mahi-mahi fillet topped with a spicy Thai peanut sauce
$24.99
Crunchy Fried Fish
Rolled in cornflakes and delicately fried
$15.99
Citrus Salmon
Salmon fillet marinated in an Italian citrus seasoning & slowly oak-grilled
Lighter appetite $19.99
Full portion $22.99
Stuffed Shrimp
Sweet, plump stuffed with our lobster/crabmeat. Baked in citrus butter, topped with a light, creamy shrimp sauce
$23.99
Stuffed Flounder
Tender mild flounder fillet packed with our famous lobster/crabmeat blend, baked in citrus butter, topped with a light, creamy seafood sauce
$25.99
Key Largo Style Baked Fish
Mild tilapia fillet topped with fresh tomatoes, onions, capers, white wine, fresh basil and lemon juice
$18.99
Sea bass add $5.99
Lobster-N–Crab Cake
Blend of lobster and blue crab sautéed or fried
Single cake $24.99
Double cake $29.99
Fire Grilled Boneless Chicken Breast
Finished with your choice of honey lime sauce, cajun seasoning, Jamaican jerk, black cherry pepper
Lighter appetite $15.99
Full portion $17.99
Black Cherry Pepper Pork
Thick juicy boneless pork loin finished over our oakwood grill and topped with our signature black cherry pepper sauce
$16.99
Keys Combo
Mahi fillet and skewered shrimp grilled over an oak-wood fire. Seasoned or basted with your choice of baste or glaze
$26.99
8 Oz Sirloin Steak
Certified sirloin oak-grilled to perfection
$24.99
Bahama Mahi
Pan sautéed mahi topped with mango salsa
$25.99
New Orleans Sea Bass
Pan sautéed with sweet pecan praline butter sauce
$24.99
Sea Bass Lorenzo
Baked with garlic butter and capers
$24.99
Raw Bar
Clams Raw* or Steamed
Full dozen $10.99
U-Peel Shrimp
Hot $14
Chilled $12.99
Oysters*
When available
Dozen $19.99
Soups & Salads
Bahamian Conch Chowder
Cup $6.99
Bowl $8.99
Caesar Salad
Fresh Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese tossed in our key-lime Caesar dressing and topped with seasoned croutons
$12.99
Garden Salad
Fresh cut lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, carrot, and red cabbage. Served with our homemade orange balsamic vinaigrette dressing
$11.99
Our Salad
Baby greens, tomato, red onion, white raisins, candied pecans and dried cranberries, lightly tossed in our signature vanilla vinaigrette dressing and topped with bleu cheese crumbles
$13.99
Grilled shrimp skewer on any salad add $6.99
Grilled mahi-mahi on any salad add $9.99
Grilled tuna or salmon on any salad add $10.99
Grilled chicken or Lip LickersTM on any salad add $5.99
